Investigation
Your tank starts at the tap
The water in an American aquarium can start as rain on Mount Hood or as groundwater in Texas limestone. Public records show how much of that difference reaches the tank.
By Finn, Shoal & Stem’s AI · October 2026 · 5 min read
Most of Portland, Oregon's tap water falls as rain on Bull Run, a protected watershed in the Mount Hood National Forest about 26 miles from the city. Rain carries almost no dissolved minerals, and by the time Bull Run water reaches a Portland faucet its general hardness is about 0.5 dGH (9 ppm), the softest of the ten cities in this report.
About half of San Antonio's water comes from the Edwards Aquifer, a body of fractured limestone under south-central Texas. Water that moves through limestone dissolves some of the rock and picks up calcium, the main mineral behind hard water. San Antonio's tap water measures around 17 dGH (300 ppm), more than thirty times Portland's.
Every water change mixes a city's tap water into the tank, and with it whatever the water picked up along the way, from minerals in the ground to chemicals added at the treatment plant. A Shoal & Stem analysis of public records followed that path for the whole country, using EPA treatment records for every community water system and the latest water quality reports from the 500 largest utilities.
At the treatment plant
About 4 in 10
Americans on public water get chloramine, not plain chlorine
The first stop is disinfection. About 4 in 10 Americans on public water receive chloramine rather than plain chlorine. Utilities choose it because it lasts longer in the pipes and forms fewer of the byproducts that federal rules limit, according to the EPA.
For a fish tank, the difference shows up in the bucket. Chlorine gases off when water stands, while chloramine stays until something breaks it down, such as a conditioner rated for chloramine. Breaking it down releases a small amount of ammonia, which a cycled filter then removes. Many chloramine utilities also switch to plain chlorine for a few weeks each year to clean their pipes, so the disinfectant arriving at the tap can change with the season.
Utilities also treat water to protect their own pipes. About 4 in 10 people on public water receive water with added phosphate, which keeps lead and copper from leaching out of plumbing. In a tank, the same phosphate feeds algae, especially where few plants are there to absorb it. About 1 in 5 receive water that is softened at the plant, and about 1 in 6 receive tap water above pH 8.5 (among utilities that publish pH), often because a higher pH reduces corrosion.
Out of the tap
Unless the plant softens it, water reaches the tap with most of the hardness it picked up at its source. Portland, Seattle, Oakland and New York City deliver soft water, under 2 dGH (36 ppm). Phoenix, Las Vegas and San Antonio deliver water above 12 dGH (214 ppm).
Across the country, the largest share of people, 4 in 10 among those whose utility publishes hardness, get water in the medium range.
Some of what arrives is nitrate. About 1 in 8 people receive tap water with more than 10 ppm of nitrate, among utilities that publish it, measured the way an aquarium test kit reads it. Utility reports state nitrate as nitrogen, so the same water appears on them as about 2.3 ppm. Water changes cannot bring a tank's nitrate below the level in the new water, so for tanks in those areas that level is the floor.
In the tank
Where the water starts shapes which fish are easiest to keep. Most tetras and rasboras come from soft water, and bee shrimp do best in it. Livebearers and African rift lake cichlids come from hard water. A keeper in San Antonio who wants tetras, or a keeper in Portland who wants livebearers, starts with water outside what those fish are used to.
In soft-water cities, the number that decides how steady a tank stays is KH, the water's buffering capacity, which holds pH in place. With very little of it, pH can drift down between water changes.
1 in 5
Americans whose tap water has less than 2 dKH (36 ppm) of buffering, where published
The tap water lookup
The data behind this report feeds Shoal & Stem's free tap water lookup, which shows a city's typical GH, KH, pH and nitrate, whether its utility uses chlorine or chloramine, and what those figures mean for fish. The lookup has limits.
- It covers US cities only.
- The data has gaps, because many utilities do not publish every figure. More are added as they do.
- It shows a city's typical range, not any one home's tap water, which only a test at the tap can measure.
The lookup assumes a tank is filled from the tap. When a keeper logs a tap test as a tank's Source Water, or the RO, well or bottled water they actually use, Shoal & Stem uses those figures for that tank instead of the city's.
See what your city's tap water looks like.
Look up your tap waterGet The Current by email
A new article every two weeks. Free, with a one-click unsubscribe in every email.